Can We Save Corals? Using Models and Evidence to Evaluate Solutions

Students investigate coral bleaching and evaluate human intervention solutions through ecosystem modeling, data analysis, evidence sorting, and CER argumentation.

Can We Save Corals? Using Models and Evidence to Evaluate Solutions

Lesson Plan by Jennifer Langston

Lesson Overview
Grades:
Key Concepts:
  • Coral reefs
  • Ecosystems
  • Symbiotic relationship
  • Climate change
  • Coral bleaching
  • Nature of Science
  • Genetic engineering
Activities:
  • Ecosystem Modeling
  • Data Analysis & Discussion
  • Evidence Sorting
  • CER (Claim, Evidence, Reasoning) & Peer Review
Time Needed:

2 x 50

minutes

Students will investigate how coral reefs function as interconnected ecosystems and examine the causes and impacts of coral bleaching. Using the Corals: On the Brink video as a phenomenon, students will analyze how rising ocean temperatures, climate change, and human activities affect coral survival. Through image analysis, ecosystem modeling, data analysis, evidence sorting, and CER argumentation, students will use scientific evidence to evaluate whether humans should intervene to help save coral reefs.

Climate change is the biggest threat to coral reefs. Can we use modern genetic tools as one method to help us understand coral biology and perhaps make corals more adaptive to climate change?

View Video Details

NGSS:

  • MS-LS2-2: Construct an explanation that predicts patterns of interactions among organisms across multiple ecosystems.
  • MS-LS2-4: Construct an argument supported by empirical evidence that changes to physical or biological components of an ecosystem affect populations.
  • MS-ESS3-5: Ask questions to clarify evidence of the factors that have caused the rise in global temperatures over the past century.
  • MS-LS4-5: Gather and synthesize information about technologies that have changed the way humans influence the inheritance of desired traits in organisms.
  • Science & Engineering Practice: Engaging in Argument from Evidence
  • NGSS Crosscutting Concepts: Cause and Effect; Systems and System Models

This is a 2-day lesson plan consisting of:

  • Day 1: Introduction to Coral Reefs and Coral Bleaching (50 minutes)
  • Day 2: Ecosystem Modeling & Data Analysis (50 minutes)

Subject Areas: Earth and Environmental Science | Life Science | Ecology | Marine Science

Prior Knowledge: Basic ecosystem concepts (e.g., food webs, energy flow, and interactions between organisms), symbiosis, photosynthesis, experience interpreting graphs and data, participating in scientific discussions, and constructing Claim-Evidence-Reasoning (CER) responses using scientific evidence

Learning Objectives:

  • Explain the symbiotic relationship between coral and zooxanthellae algae.
  • Analyze how rising ocean temperatures contribute to coral bleaching and ecosystem disruption.
  • Model interactions within a coral reef ecosystem and predict how changes affect the food web.
  • Interpret data and visual evidence related to coral bleaching trends over time.
  • Construct a scientific argument using evidence to support a claim about human intervention in coral reef conservation.
  • Reflect on the benefits and risks of proposed scientific solutions such as genetic engineering and coral restoration.

Materials Needed:

  • Projector & computer with internet access to play videos and slides
  • Student worksheets (download below)
  • Ecosystem Modeling Activity Cards (download below)
  • Yarn

Lesson Activities: Login to Download Lesson

Introduction to Coral Bleaching (5 minutes)

First, introduce students to the phenomenon. Ask students to read Part I of the Day 1 Student Worksheet, a READING influenced by Corals: On the Brink.  

Image Analysis: Bleached versus Unbleached Coral (10 minutes)

Ask students to observe the image and answer the questions independently (Part II of the Day 1 Student Worksheet). After students answer the questions, lead a group discussion to review the students' answers (Think-Pair-Share). 

Video Watching and Discussion (20-30 minutes)

Show students the Corals: On the Brink video and ask students to complete the Part III questions of the Day 1 Student Worksheet. 

Closing (5 minutes)

Ask students to complete the Exit Ticket questions in Part IV of the Day 1 Student Worksheet.

Teachers Only: Answer Key

Please see the Day 1 Student Worksheet - Answer Key.

Coral Reef Ecosystem Modeling Activity (20-30 minutes)

Through this activity, students will model the complex interactions within a coral reef ecosystem and observe how disruptions can trigger cascading effects throughout the system.

Divide the class into groups of approximately 16 students and have each group stand or sit in a circle. Assign each student an organism or abiotic factor within the coral reef ecosystem and provide them with the corresponding Coral Reef Ecosystem Card. Each card describes the role of that organism or factor and its connections to other components of the ecosystem.

Before beginning, give students time to review their cards and become familiar with their assigned roles. Then, follow the instructions provided in the Coral Reef Ecosystem Modeling Activity guidelines. You may read the prompts aloud as students work through the model and experience how changes to individual components can lead to cascading effects and, ultimately, ecosystem collapse.

After completing the model, lead a whole-class discussion to help students reflect on what they observed and learned. Encourage students to identify important relationships within the ecosystem and consider how the disruption or loss of one component can affect the system as a whole.

Use guiding questions to deepen the discussion, such as: “Why did some changes have a greater impact on the ecosystem than others?” and “Which organisms or factors seemed most important to the stability of the ecosystem, and why?

Coral Bleaching Events: Data Analysis (10–20 minutes)

Ask students to complete Part I of the Day 2 Student Worksheet. In this activity, students practice analyzing and interpreting data related to coral bleaching events. Encourage students to examine patterns in the data, interpret the results, and consider how the evidence connects to concepts explored throughout the lesson.

Coral Bleaching Evidence Sorting (10 minutes)

In this activity, students evaluate a series of statements and classify each as evidence, opinion, or uncertain/needs additional information. Students should justify each classification using ONLY evidence and information they have encountered throughout the lesson, including the Phenomenon Reading (Day 1), Corals: On the Brink video (Day 1), Data Analysis activity (Day 2), and Coral Reef Ecosystem Modeling Activity (Day 2).

This activity provides an opportunity for students to synthesize what they have learned while practicing how to distinguish scientific evidence from opinions or claims that require additional information. Students may complete the activity individually or in small groups by answering the questions in Part II of the Day 2 Student Worksheet. 

CER Activity & Peer Review (10–20 minutes)

Ask students to complete Part III of the Day 2 Student Worksheet independently. Students will respond to a guiding question by developing a claim and supporting it with relevant evidence and reasoning from the lesson.

After students complete their CER responses, have them work in pairs to complete Part IV of the Day 2 Student Worksheet. This section guides students through reviewing a partner’s CER and providing constructive feedback on the strength of the claim, evidence, and reasoning.

After the peer-review process, give students time to consider the feedback they received and revise their CER responses before submitting them for final review.

Teachers Only: Answer Key

Please see the Day 2 Student Worksheet - Answer Key.

For Deeper Learning

  • Students can research additional reef restoration strategies, such as coral gardening, artificial reefs, or marine protected areas, and compare their effectiveness in a presentation or infographic.
  • Advanced learners can investigate CRISPR and genetic engineering in greater depth and evaluate ethical considerations through a structured debate or position paper.

For Diverse Learners

  • Provide sentence starters, vocabulary supports, and guided CER templates for students who need additional writing support.
  • Use visuals, diagrams, and color-coded ecosystem models to support comprehension of reef interactions and food webs.
  • Offer simplified readings or chunked video questions for students who benefit from reduced text complexity.
  • Challenge advanced learners to design their own reef conservation solution supported by scientific evidence.

Extension Activities

  • Coral Conservation Campaign: Students create a digital poster, infographic, or short public service announcement explaining the causes of coral bleaching and actions people can take to help protect reefs.

More Info:

  • Small groups of 3–4 students work best for discussion, evidence sorting, and CER peer review because all students have opportunities to participate.
  • For the ecosystem web activity, clear an open space in the classroom so students can safely form a large circle and move during disturbance events.
  • Assign student roles strategically to support participation and classroom management during the modeling activity.
  • Pause the video periodically to check for understanding and allow students time to process complex scientific ideas and ethical questions.
  • Providing both digital and printable versions of activities increases accessibility and flexibility for different classroom settings and learning needs.
  • Visual supports, sentence stems, and guided notes are helpful for students who need additional reading or writing support.
  • Encourage respectful discussion during the CER and genetic engineering debate activities, as students may have differing opinions about human intervention in nature.
  • This lesson is designed for students to complete digitally using online documents, slides, and discussion tools; however, all activities and materials can easily be adapted into printable paper-based formats if technology access is limited.

What Worked Well:

  • The Coral Reef Ecosystem Modeling Activity was highly engaging because students could physically see how organisms in an ecosystem depend on one another and how disturbances create cascading effects.
  • The Corals: On the Brink video helped students connect scientific concepts to real-world environmental issues and sparked meaningful discussions about climate change and human intervention.
  • The CER argumentation and evidence sort activities were effective in helping students distinguish between evidence, opinion, and uncertainty while supporting claims with scientific reasoning.

Student understanding was assessed throughout the lesson using discussion questions, image analysis responses, data interpretation activities, and class participation during the ecosystem modeling activity. Students demonstrated learning through evidence sorting, written CER (Claim-Evidence-Reasoning) responses, peer review feedback, and an exit slip that included both multiple-choice and short-answer questions requiring students to explain coral bleaching and evaluate possible solutions.

What My Students Learned:

  • Students developed a deeper understanding of coral reef ecosystems and the symbiotic relationship between coral and algae.
  • Students recognized how human activities, especially climate change, can disrupt ecosystems and contribute to biodiversity loss.
  • Students improved their ability to analyze scientific data, evaluate evidence, and construct evidence-based arguments about environmental issues.
  • Students explored how scientists use creativity, technology, and problem-solving to develop possible solutions to real-world challenges such as coral bleaching.
  • Students engaged in meaningful scientific discussions and considered multiple perspectives about the benefits and risks of human intervention in nature.

Like this Lesson Plan?